.
Feedback

4 Signs You Might Be a 'Helicopter Parent' -- And How You Can Stop

Are you in danger of becoming a "Helicopter Parent?" Find out the signs and how you can avoid this trend from two SCSU family therapy experts.

 

It is an unspoken right – and even social expectation -- among those who have reached a certain age to express concern about the younger generations. You know the comments:

  • “Kids today just don’t have any respect for authority.”
  • “What’s going to happen when these kids start running the country? We are going to be in serious trouble.”
  • And a host of remarks that begin with something like…“When we were growing up, we didn’t have…”

But today, perhaps more than at any other time since the height of the Baby Boom Generation, parenting styles also have taken the spotlight. We hear much of what happens if you raise your children without structure and rules, and what happens if you have too much structure and too many rules. We hear about raising your kids with too much self-esteem and not enough self-esteem. And you might remember all the media attention paid to the “Tiger Mom” and how it prompted a national discussion about parenting.

Nevertheless, it is the phenomenon of Helicopter Parents that is the most discussed and analyzed by professional psychologists, family therapy experts, parents and educators. The consensus is that this type of parenting, while often well-intended, tends to do more harm than good. For those who may not have heard of the term, it refers to parents who are overly involved in their children’s lives and who tend to “micromanage” their kids’ day. In many instances, this “hyper-involvement” continues into the college years and sometimes even beyond. The consequences of this type of parenting style can include hindering kids’ ability to gain a proper amount of age-appropriate independence and to solve their own problems.

Suzanne Carroll, professor of marriage and family therapy at Southern, and Phyllis Gordon, manager of the university’s Family Therapy Clinic, are quite familiar with this trend. Both say that many people might not even be aware that they have fallen into the Helicopter Parents category. They offer four examples of how you know you are probably a Helicopter Parent:

  • You are doing homework assignments for your child or are frequently checking to make sure they’ve done them.
  • You are the one managing their responsibilities, such as doing their homework, waking up on time and attending athletic team practices.
  • You refer to your child’s team, club or organization as “we.” For example, saying that “we have a game today.”
  • You and your child are communicating too frequently, such as with multiple texts and/or phone calls each day.

Carroll and Gordon are not in any way suggesting that parents should be oblivious to their children’s lives. On the contrary, they underscore the importance of showing concern for their children’s well-being. But being overly involved in their lives can create long-term problems. Here are some suggestions that Carroll and Gordon offer to strike that balance of being a responsible mom or dad without being a Helicopter Parent:

  • Set REALISTIC goals and expectations with your child, based on their age and abilities.
  • Work with your child to make a plan (if needed), on how to meet those goals/expectations.
  • Step back. Have your child take responsibility for meeting those goals/expectations.
  • Be prepared to renegotiate.
  • Let your child accept the natural consequences of their efforts.

Carroll and Gordon recognize that resisting the inclination of parents to “fix” their children’s every problem or task can be difficult – especially at first. After all, it is perfectly natural for parents not to want to see their children struggle. And, of course, there are times when swift parental intervention is necessary. But a consistent pattern of micromanaging can have significant consequences as a child gets older and enters the world of adulthood.

“Remember, parenting is the illusion of control,” Carroll says.

For additional reading about the phenomenon of Helicopter Parents, check out a recent column written by Anne Michaud, interactive editor at Newsday.

Digby February 27, 2013 at 07:13 pm
There’s an underlying premises I disagree with here. Some parents believe that if you let your child fend for himself, then he will learn responsibility. I’m not sure that’s true. I think he learns to be mediocre.
If you let a 7th grader write a book report and you don’t interact with him, on average he will get an average grade. What does that tell him? For one thing he learns that getting a B is okay in his parents’ eyes. So why should he work any harder? Mom and Dad don’t seem to care. Is that him learning responsibility? Or is that him learning how to squeak by with minimal effort? Contrast that with the child of the conscientious parent. The 7th grader has to write a book report. The conscientious parent talks about what kinds of books the child might find interesting. After the chosen book is read, the conscientious parent asks the child questions about the themes in the book. The conscientious parent reads the report and comments on poor grammar and unsupported statements. A learning opportunity. The parent augments what the teacher is doing. In the end, the child of the conscientious parent puts in X times the effort. Do the conscientious parents write the report. No, that would be wrong. But the conscientious parents help the child understand that a great effort is expected and achievable.
Digby February 27, 2013 at 07:14 pm
Who do you want to hire 10 years from the now. Who will be more successful in life? The kid who thinks average is just fine? Or the kid who learned that you can do a great job, but it takes a lot of enjoyable effort?
I think non-helicopter parents are hiding behind some misinformation that they have somehow taught their kids to be more responsible. I think it is not true. The child of the conscientious parent turns out to be much more responsible.
J D C February 27, 2013 at 07:33 pm
Yes, i would hire the person that strives for excellence as long as the parents don't have to be on the payroll in order for him or her to achieve it.
Lyners February 27, 2013 at 07:49 pm
Digby--the interactions you describe in terms of working with a 7th grader on a book report are, in my mind, being a good parent, and supporting a child. They do NOT describe a helicopter parent. An extreme helicopter parent would read the book and write the book report, and even go so far as to creatively design a cover using advanced art skills. Your average helicopter parent might not write the whole thing, but would end up writing a majority of the report, as they would probably heavily edit the child's work--inserting a lot of their own writing
As teachers, we DO want parents who are involved with their children and in their child's education. I think we also believe in the concept of gradual release of responsibility. What I mean by that is that, year by year, as parents, we want to work towards having our children take on more and more responsibility as far as homework goes. The eventual aim is for them to be able to plan their afternoon, knowing what's going on after school, and scheduling their homework time in accordingly. They should be able to eventually plan out how they will tackle long-term homework assignments. They should come to you, (rather than you asking to see it) for editing help, with any essay-type assignments. My high school aged son knows that his father and I are always available to help him with his homework--all he needs to do is ask. What we don't do is constantly monitor him. He gets good grades, and so there is no need.
Lyners February 27, 2013 at 07:57 pm
To continue...
With our older son, when he started high school, his grades weren't very good, and, after talking with his teachers, we learned that the grades reflected his poor homework grades. In that instance, we took a much more hands-on approach with him. He knew he would have to show us his planner every day. He knew that, after he had finished his homework, he would have to show it to us and show that it was a reflection of what he had written down in his planner. After doing this for several months, we gradually dialed back the checking on him, until he finally could handle it on his own. Then he was finally in the situation like we are now with our other, younger son. He was on the honor roll, and felt very good about the fact that he was managing his work himself. I think, Digby, we really have more in common than you are thinking. I am enjoying our well thought out discussion, and I respect your interest in the topic, and the care and commitment you have as a mother!
onceuponanewtown February 27, 2013 at 09:49 pm
This is sadly true. Why is our community so terrified when they do see groups of kids out in public...they need to begin their independence somewhere. They feel locked in, too, there isn't a place where they can go without being micromanaged.
Robert Bracer February 27, 2013 at 10:03 pm
@ farm guy, the problem with Madison is if you don't watch every practice the coaches get seduced by the soccer moms into playing her kid even though the kid doesn't deserve playing time. It has been happening for ever in Madison, if you're not watching; the lousy kids get the PT. Actually though when the lousy kid gets the starting position all the rest of the other kids know what is up and the lousy kids is a joke forever. So Madison soccer moms and MAdison LAX Dads, when your kid sucks, they really do.
sebastian dangerfield February 27, 2013 at 11:45 pm
digby says
"There is an overwhelming attitude around here that if anyone does better than our own children... well.... that person must have cheated, or they must be insulted, or they must be punished in some other way. " Then digby says "I said something that bruised your ego, so you need to put me down. Goes to exactly what I am talking about." Do you even hear what youre saying? You go through this entire litany of who the 'other' parents are. If they complain about helicopter parents, then they are pot smoking, ego driven, low brow racists. But-not you. You are the exception and all the parents that dont conform to your approach are losing. Ie--the 'overwhelming attitude." Could you let me know if all those insults are not 'put downs?" Or are you saying that you can accuse people, judge people, and insult people--but if someone does it to you--then , well they are covering something up? I mean are you so self righteous that you cannot even notice all the crap you just hurled at an entiire town, while at the same time saying no one is allowed to question you? Wow
sebastian dangerfield February 27, 2013 at 11:52 pm
Digby
Simple question. Your child gets a B in a subject. What happens next in your house?
sebastian dangerfield March 1, 2013 at 06:07 am
There you go!
Nice one. 1 Believe urban legend. 2- justify all decisions based on myth. Incredible that in your mind, there are all these pot smoking, sex promoting, ego invested parents. While at the same time, your daughter needs to text you about a show that aired at 7pm. Wonder what you were doing that prevented her from asking you those questions ? Maybe having a key party with your neighbors? That urban legend also exists, so lets leap to conclusions about your parenting, as you do with all the other parents. How absurd you are that you need to justify your helicopter parenting on the concept that there is rampant sex occuring on school buses. Oh my gosh the lengths that one needs to go to, in order to legitimize breast feeding your kid until they are in college.
Lisa Buchman March 1, 2013 at 02:34 pm
A reminder that users need to abide by our terms of service. Nothing obsence, accusatory, defamatory or personally attacking another individual. A few comments have been deleted. www.ridgefield.patch/terms
David Chesler March 1, 2013 at 05:59 pm
Please look at freerangekids.com
WaxyGordon March 2, 2013 at 09:22 pm
Digby, when I hear the term helicopter parent I think of a parent that does every thying for their child, so much that their child never has to make a decision or solve a personal problem by them selves. That is a disservice to that child, who will never succeed on their own.....that is different from a parent that cares about their child and provides guidance, but does not do their school projects for them
WaxyGordon March 2, 2013 at 09:24 pm
Helicopter parents have created a generation of kids that have no idea how to help them selves and solve life's problems and are doomed to fail in life once their parents can no longer 'hover around ' them and do everything for them, school projects, applications, job interviews.
Sally Ride March 2, 2013 at 11:19 pm
Then Waxy, by all means, don't help your kids with their homework. It will lower the bell curve for the rest of our children. Thanks.
Great blog, as expected. I am glad I found you on Patch.com. Note to parents: Please try to trust your kids, and PLEASE, do not fill out their college apps or write their essays for them!
Alex March 6, 2013 at 11:07 pm
"It is an unspoken right – and even social expectation -- among those who have reached a certain age to express concern about the younger generations. "
It's not even that. I look at the Gen X and Gen Y parents of today and shake my head in disgust. I'm a millennial and tell myself everyday that I will not do what these "parents" do. Read the book, "The 4th turning: An American Philosophy". The author did an amazing job describing the cyclical events of each generation and how it can help predict where we are going as a society. Its very interesting and gave me a lot of insight on why parents of today's generation behave the way they do and what kind of generation you were born in and how that affects your life path.
Alex March 6, 2013 at 11:14 pm
Will the parents be calling when their son or daughter is upset from a bad day at work? If so, no thanks.
95% proficiency that takes 5 hours is better than 100% proficiency that takes 10 hours. At a certain point you're just wasting time trying to be perfect.
yinyang March 6, 2013 at 11:49 pm
Im a high school teacher. I have had many parents email or call explaining why little Johnny (who is 15-18 years old) didn't do his HW. Some examples: " I forgot to wake him up from his nap, please let him hand it in late." or "He told me to email his HW when he went out with friends and I forgot, so it was my fault. Please don't penalize him for my mistake." I have had kids cut class, admit it, then come back the next day with a note from a parent claiming they had picked their kid up for a dentist appointment and that's why he wasn't in class. The list goes on....parents are so anxious to cover for their kids that the kids never have to suffer the consequences for their own screw ups. These kids will someday be shocked when they lose a job or end up in jail because Mom and Dad can't shield them from the consequences of their bigger screw ups as adults.
Daniella Ruiz March 6, 2013 at 11:50 pm
what are most parents expectations of their child? a follower in the family business, a fully independent actor with no need for support, a free-wheeler with endless ideas and able to engage in all of life's challenges?
each child as others mentioned, have vastly differing aspirations, capacity and ability. good children result from giving the kid the right 'kick of encouragement' at the right time, & knowing when requires involvement, rather than 'management'. being fully aware of the child, respecting and sustaining a clear communication pathway is the basis for trust. absolute power corrupts absolutely i was told, it denies development and the integral thought process's needed (and they vary) at each stage of young peoples lives. throw in chemical adulterants (Drugs of any sort) and the child will be altered, and denied the full capacity the of their normal brain. if you ever see kids 'outa control', if and when, then there's a significant communication issue in play, both ways. it's not a one way street, excepting known dysfunction or physical issues. frustration is not a 'child only' condition either, adults can and will experience it. perfect children don't exist, never will, and we as parents are a testament to that.
Mary Poppins March 7, 2013 at 12:20 am
I have to agree 100% with WaxyGordon and yinyang. There is nothing wrong with guiding a child, the problem is the helicopter parent not only guides, but completes the task. I work at a company where we have alot of seasonal employees..1/2 high school, 1/2 college. You would be appalled by the number of parents (both mothers and fathers) who fill out employment applications and who call/come in to inquire about the status of their child's employment application. We actually had a mom come to a scheduled interview because her child couldn't make it! Guess who didn't get the job. If Johnny/Susie can not fill out an application, inquire about the status, guess who doesn't get an interview. We had one employee who couldn't come to work one day, so instead of calling us or finding a substitute, his mother came to do his job!!! These types of helicopter parents are doing a grace injustice to their children because one day mommy and daddy will not be there to bail them out.
Sarah C March 7, 2013 at 01:03 am
The youngest of my four children is 24, so it's been a while since I had a 7th grader. I want to say that you cannot really control a teenager, but you can retain control of their environment. You don't have to pay for inappropriate clothing, a cell phone, or car insurance. And if, from the time they were tots, you raised your kids to understand the difference between right and wrong, good and evil, moral and immoral, they won't stray too far when they are teens.
Digby March 9, 2013 at 05:43 am
My apologies Lisa. I think you had to delete my posts because I used what is considered foul language. Wasn't really my intention to use bad words. I was trying to relay what happened and what was said by others. Guess I should have said it in an alternate way. I understand you deleting the posts.
Funny how it works though isn't it. I just relayed what some adults inappropriately said in front of school children, and I rightfully get censored. Yet the adults who made the original statements, who is there to censor them from saying such things in front of the kids? Such is life I guess. Again, apologies for using those words.
Marcia Puc March 9, 2013 at 01:18 pm
This is so true. I would much rather, as hard as it is, give my kids the freedom and responsibility to "fail" while they are in middle school (regarding missed assignments, etc). This enables them to experience real life while still under my wings, so to speak. If you keep coddling them and steering them all through their childhood, they will melt later in life when confronted with a difficult situation - because they have never been allowed to feel disappointment or failure. They will have no idea how to pick themselves up and move on. Let them learn now while you are still there to comfort and teach them in an age-appropriate manner. I think if we do this we will have a lot less twenty/thirty year olds living at home relying on mom & dad (emotionally and or financially)
Susan Parent March 9, 2013 at 02:06 pm
I did not participate in my children's homework unless they asked for help. They wrote their own papers and learned to edit their own work. They were expected to give a top effort at their studies, and if after giving it their all only managed to get a C, that was ok. What I did give them was a place to do their work and lots of love. Somehow they all managed to become honor roll students, were accepted into colleges of their choice, and were dean's list students. Two of the three chose to continue with graduate degrees and completed their degrees with a 4.0 GPA. All are working in their chosen fields.
Was I not conscientious?
Lora March 9, 2013 at 02:08 pm
Wow, no wonder the kids can't get along. There's nothing wrong with being involved with your child, you should be. You should know if their homework is done, some kids don't need prompting, , some need a little push and others need to be held in the chair until the homework is finished. If you have more than one child, you know each one requires something different. Don't know how to use social networking?..LEARN....simply to keep your child safe. They unfriended you? Great..take away their access until you are friended...they will find a way around you..and your job is to figure it out. Maybe the difference is this: ex. Another child said something to make your child upset or cry. The helicopter parent screams at the school, the other parents and whoever else they perceive to be responsible. The involved parent talks to their child (and they know their child is upset, and that the event happened BECAUSE they are involved) and discusses ways to handle the situation and ALSO uses it as a learning tool to build a conscience in their child by saying, "see how you are feeling right now? It doesn't feel very nice right? Ok, I want you to remember that and make sure YOU never make someone else feel like that"...that helps them build compassion and you will find they will be the first to stand up for someone else. A helicopter parent isn't one that is involved and interested and present and monitoring of their child's life...that's a good parent.
John Yannacci, Sr. March 9, 2013 at 02:45 pm
I thought that I was moderately intelligent and I have absolutely no idea what a 5x5 is.
John Yannacci, Sr. March 9, 2013 at 02:48 pm
I think it means, "Like, you gotta, like, go slow."
Digby March 10, 2013 at 07:46 pm
Danielle: "good children result from giving the kid the right 'kick of encouragement' at the right time."
But when is the right time? Do we leave them to their own devices starting in 7th grade and tell them to give a call if the decide to go to college? I say no way. They still need guidance all the way through high school and beyond. yinyang: "Im a high school teacher...These kids will someday be shocked when they lose a job or end up in jail because Mom and Dad can't shield them from the consequences of their bigger screw ups as adults." I'm saddened to think you are a teacher. I would expect a more nurturing personality in a teacher. Susan Parent: "if after giving it their all only managed to get a C, that was ok." I think this is wrong. You showed your kids that a C is okay. How does that prepare them for life, to show them a bad job is acceptable? Getting a C means they have poor academic habits. This isn't for the child to fix. It needs the parents' intervention. "Somehow they all managed to become honor roll students, were accepted into colleges of their choice, and were dean's list students. Two of the three chose to continue with graduate degrees and completed their degrees with a 4.0 GPA. All are working in their chosen fields. Was I not conscientious?" It depends. Maybe they only had "C" ambitions and they now work at the mall.
yinyang March 11, 2013 at 02:57 am
Digby- you should be more saddened that a parent would cover for their kids who cut class, lie, and expect their parents to make excuses for their bad behavior. That's what you call nurturing? Trust me, in 25 years of teaching I have seen the negative consequences for kids when their parents never allow them to experience the consequences for their actions. The parents do their kids no favors; in fact it is terribly detrimental, regardless of whether the parents have good intentions. So, your definition of nurturing is certainly not mine....I consider nurturing to be somethng which is beneficial to kids. And no matter how much I would sometimes like to shield my own kids from their mistakes, I try to remember all the times I've seen this done with such negative outcomes.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Hamden Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Katie Skeeles
Mary L June 10, 2013 at 04:34 pm
Congratulations Katie! I know you worked very hard on this project. You should be very proud!
Jo Waznis June 13, 2013 at 04:17 pm
Congrats, Katie--it's a great accomplishment!